Ministry News

Believing Big (and Small)

It doesn't take a rocket scientist to determine there are major differences between a church of 1,000-plus people and another with 100 or fewer. But apparently, it took a research guru to prove the beliefs in those churches are vastly different as well.

According to The Barna Group, those attending larger churches are more likely to line up with Scripture in their beliefs than those attending smaller churches. Of the 3,000 adults surveyed, 74 percent of large-church attendees agree that Jesus didn't sin while on earth, compared to a surprising 49 percent of small-church members. Only 30 percent of small-church members think Satan is an actual living being, and 33 percent believe a good person can't earn a place in heaven. That's compared to 51 percent and 55 percent, respectively, of those in churches with more than 1,000 people.

When it comes to sharing the gospel, only 41 percent of congregants in a church of 100 people or fewer say it's a personal responsibility to evangelize, while 61 percent of large-church attendees believe this to be the case. And three-quarters of those going to a large church agree that the Bible is completely accurate in all its principles (60 percent of small-church regulars said this).

Overall, the recent Barna report indicates that the major belief differences between small and large churches is most evident at the threshold of 200 attendees. Interestingly enough, only 9 percent of American churchgoers attend a church of 1,000 people or more, while a whopping 41 percent go to churches of 100 or fewer.

An additional note for those involved in house churches: Barna says the beliefs and behaviors of those involved in house churches (average attendance: 20 adults) are actually more aligned with those who attend larger churches (500 or more adults) than with the conventional small-church crowd. [barna.org, 8/10/09]

Comments   

 
+6 #10 katocha 2009-08-13 09:02
I think this is not about how large or small the church is,
its about the teachings and practices that pastor or leaders show to their congregation to follow.
Quote
 
 
-2 #9 D Stambaugh 2009-08-12 07:45
I don't know what you guys are talking about, this makes perfect sense. small churches are small because pastors don't disciple and people don't make evangelism a priority, if they did...they wouldn't be small! Healthy, Biblical Churches Grow, not all growing church or large churches are healthy, but all healthy churches will grow, there is no way they can't! They will accidently grow if people are discipled and evangelism is a priority. I grew up in a small church and i pastor what is currently a small church...but it won't be for long.
Quote
 
 
+1 #8 snowbird 2009-08-12 07:29
Talk about a delusional deception, if you believe this farce you'll believe anything!! This is such an elaborate joke it so reminds me of the worldly media these days. Did they print this just to see the reaction? I was raised on the edge of country...meaning I was 2 miles from town at the tip of what leads into country. Oh what freedom we thought we enjoyed to really mess up our lives. But I could climb to the top of trees as a child and make one sided conversations with God...altho I was a sinner, I didn't exactly know what that was at the time so I just needed to talk to someone I could trust. I also wrote him letters a lot. When I was supernaturally borned again I suddenly realized that he had heard and read every word. Try telling that to thousands of large dignified well dressed prideful church members today. But its still the truth!!!
Quote
 
 
+2 #7 GlennPettit 2009-08-11 17:10
Sorry for the double-post. Browser issues.
Quote
 
 
+5 #6 GlennPettit 2009-08-11 17:08
Personally, I find the Barna surveys less and less relevant. For one, they survey such a statistically small sample that their conclusions can hardly be said to apply to the overall American population. Also, many recent Barna surveys cannot be broken down by denomination because the survey sample is so small. And as for the conclusion of this survey: You'd be hard-pressed to match that against the small Bible-based non-denominational churches in my area. We are FAR more conservative that the bigger churches - which are, of course, mainline denominations.
Quote
 
 
+1 #5 GlennPettit 2009-08-11 17:07
Personally, I find the Barna surveys less and less relevant. For one, they survey such a statistically small sample that their conclusions can hardly be said to apply to the overall American population. Also, many recent Barna surveys cannot be broken down by denomination because the survey sample is so small. And as for the conclusion of this survey: You'd be hard-pressed to match that against the small Bible-based non-denominational churches in my area. We are FAR more conservative that the bigger churches - which are, of course, mainline denominations.
Quote
 
 
+4 #4 PDawson 2009-08-11 12:49
I'd be curious to see what churches were polled as well... considering that a large % of larger churches seem to be more evangelical and non-denominational while the majority of mainline congregations probably fit within the "less than 100" catagory. I wouldn't be a bit surprised if the real research showed that this was not a church size phenomanon, but a denominational background one.
Quote
 
 
+8 #3 imed 2009-08-11 12:11
Only in America. The Christians in Zimbabwe, Zambia, Botswana, Mainland China and Nigeria I've met personally meet in very small quarters and homes. They literally cling to their Bibles memorizing and devouring chapters so they may give those chapter pages from them to those pastors and lay workers who have none. Perhaps we need more of a "world focus" overall.
Quote
 
 
+4 #2 Sojourner Truth 2009-08-11 12:00
Unfortunately, Barna Group's research is not always trustworthy. Recently referred to in Ministry Today, a Barna poll showing differences in black and white Christians stated with 95% certainty that the research is correct. Yet the ratio of whites to blacks polled is about six to one. The Group is shifty about providing data showing how their information is gathered, from whom, and for what purpose. Unfortunately, Ministry Today is still quoting Barna like his research is Scripture. Get over it. He makes a living by making headlines.
Quote
 
 
+9 #1 MarilynB 2009-08-11 11:03
I'd be curious to know what denominations Barna interviewed. I think he would find just the opposite results in mainline churches like the Episcopal Church and the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America. The smaller churches are decidedly more biblical.
Quote
 

Add comment


Security code
Refresh

CHANNELS:
Visit Charisma magazineVisit SpiritLed WomanVisit Ministry Today magazineVisit Vida Cristiana
advertisement
Download the Vacation Bible School 2012 guide
advertisement

Subscribe to our Magazine

Ministry Today Digital

Ministry Clip of the Week

Download Video: HTML5 Video Player by VideoJS

a